I don't think Aaron was saying the wiki was failing. The problem was social. There were no leaders. Software can't fix that. --ss
Yes, wiki-the-online-community is failing, not wiki-as-a-platform. -- Alex
Do we really know this? There may be many reasons for failing. Consensus and refactoring might be difficult if technical features (diffs, revisions) are not sufficient. It would be worth analizing. The message might also be: wiki culture is not prepared to resolve real world interests. -- Helmut
Indeed. Aren't wikis conflict-avoiding in the first place? Due to the principle of EnlargeSpace opposing forces can accomodate without agreeing. Standards comitees (and most other conflict "resolving" entities) are only a way of politely kicking other opinions into their teeth. -- DavidSchmitt
You are right -- EnlargeSpace allows to avoid conflicts. Perhaps the community should have focused on producing OneText. The key is to use the conflict resolution pattern appropriate for the life cycle of the problem. -- AlexSchroeder